Posted: February 24, 2009 at 8:00 pm | Tags: Alexander, apartment, Availability, bedroom, canadian funding corp, canadian funding corporation, cent, City, CMA, CMHC, core, Downtown, East Outer, employment, homeownership, management, market, moishe alexander, number, October, Ontario, Rate, Rental Market, river, SECURITY, situation, St, unit, Vacancy, Windsor, Zone
February 24, 2009 – Moishe Alexander’s review on how the current world economy and Canadian economic turndown is affecting the Windsor Rental Market
Moishe Alexander’s Review
Highlights
Moishe Alexander says the average vacancy rate in the Windsor CMA rose to 14.6 per cent in October 2008, up from 12.8 per cent last fall. Unemployment among young persons and residents leaving to search for work elsewhere contributed to the increase. The average rental apartment vacancy rate will remain high in 2009, peaking at 17 per cent.
Demand for Rental Apartments Waned in 2008
Moishe Alexander says Demand for privately-initiated rental apartment units in the Windsor Census Metropolitan Area (CMA), waned in 2008. The already high vacancy rate increased to a record 14.6 per cent from 12.8 per cent in 2007. Vacancy rates were unchanged or higher for all apartment types. A number of factors have contributed to the rising number of vacant rental apartments in Windsor.
Migration is a key factor in housing demand. Low unemployment rates draw migrants to a centre in search of work. Windsor’s unemployment rate has been well above the provincial average over the last four years. In 2007, Windsor averaged 9.3 per cent unemployment. In 2008 the rate has exceeded 10 per cent in some months.
Not only has this poor employment scenario meant fewer people are moving to Windsor, it has also meant Windsor residents are moving elsewhere in search of work. In 2007, the Windsor CMA lost an estimated 1,700 people to other centres.
Employment among young people is another important factor in rental demand since they tend to be more likely to rent than other age groups. This group has not been spared from job losses in the area. At the same time, Statistics Canada has found a growing trend of young adults staying in the parental home longer.
The resale market currently favours buyers since prices are declining. However, fewer renters are choosing to take advantage of these conditions due to uncertain employment prospects. For example, the rent for a three-bedroom townhouse averaged $875 in October 2008, an amount which would easily allow for a monthly mortgage payment on a starter home in Windsor. Nevertheless, the total vacancy rate for townhouse units decreased from 13.7 per cent in 2007 to 11.7 per cent in 2008, indicating tenants were not moving into homeownership.
Vacancies Highest Downtown
Moishe Alexander says All four zones in Windsor City had a higher vacancy rate in 2008 due to fewer employment opportunities, outflows of residents to other regions in search of employment.
Downtown Windsor, Zone 1, had the highest vacancy rate in the CMA once again, increasing from 15.4 per cent the previous year to 17.5 per cent in 2008 . The vacancy rate increased for all apartment types. Zone 1 has traditionally had the highest vacancy rate of any Windsor zone in part due to the large proportion of older structures which often require more repairs and therefore may be considered less desirable by potential tenants.
The core has also experienced the loss of a number of commercial businesses implying fewer people will need to live there to be close to their work. The downtown is also the prime nightlife destination which may deter some potential renters who dislike the associated noise and traffic congestion. The vacancy rate for one bedroom apartments was highest in Zone 2 at 23.2 per cent. This zone has a number of smaller buildings primarily one bedroom. Smaller buildings, such as those with less than 20 units tend to have higher vacancies during periods of oversupply as tenants have options and preferences for larger buildings which tend to have more security, and professional onsite management. Rents for one bedroom units in this zone remain low in an attempt to compensate.
Traditionally in Windsor the most popular location for renters to choose is Zone 3-East Outer which had the lowest overall vacancy rate in the City at 10.6 per cent, as well as the lowest one bedroom vacancy rate at 9.5 per cent. The latter was significantly lower than the one bedroom vacancy rates in surrounding zones. This zone includes larger buildings with prime locations along the river which are more attractive to tenants. These buildings offer newer units and professional on-site management. As well the larger property management firms have the resources available to offer rental incentives which many smaller landlords do not.
Both the University of Windsor and St. Clair College are located in Zone 4. Although students are usually a source of demand for rental accommodation, the vacancy rate rose from 14.5 per cent to 14.9 per cent at the same time as the stock of apartments decreased. The completion of several new student residences over the past few years coupled with students doubling up as evidenced by the decrease in the two bedroom vacancy rate have contributed to the greater number of vacancies.
Demand for One- Bedroom Apartments Falls
Moishe Alexander says Despite a decline in the stock of onebedroom apartments, the number of vacant units rose from 1,023 units in 2007 to 1,175 in 2008 resulting in a 15.7 per cent vacancy rate. With an average difference of $127 between a one-bedroom and a two-bedroom unit, some renters would have chosen to double up and share expenses. At the same time, for people in a stable employment situation, the current situation offered an opportunity to move up to a larger apartment. Given the generally weak employment situation, there were few new tenants to move into the vacated smaller units.
Rents Stable
Moishe Alexander says CMHC has introduced a measure for the change in rents for existing structures. By focusing on existing structures, we can exclude the impact of new structures added to the rental universe between surveys and conversions and get a better indication of the rent increase in existing structures. For the Windsor CMA, a softer rental market has meant that the average rent for a two-bedroom apartment unit in an existing structure showed no significant change from October 2007 to October 2008. Landlords attempting to boost occupancy rates have held the line on rents in this very competitive market.
Newer Buildings Have Lower Vacancies
Moishe Alexander says Buildings constructed pre-1960 had the highest vacancy rate at 21.6 per cent in 2008. These buildings tend to be walk-up units near the core and in need of greater maintenance. The rates for buildings constructed in 1990 and after had the lowest vacancy rate at 10.2 per cent.
Larger Buildings Have Lowest Vacancy Rate
Moishe Alexander says The trend for larger buildings to have vacancy rates below the market average in Windsor continued in 2008. Large buildings with 100 or more units had the lowest one bedroom and second lowest two-bedroom vacancy rates despite having the highest average rents. Larger buildings are usually run by property management firms who can afford rental incentives, security, on-site superintendents and building maintenance to keep and attract tenants. These buildings also tend to have choice locations along the river in Windsor.
Smaller buildings with less than 20 units continue to have the highest vacancies for apartments with one, two and three or more bedrooms.
Availability Rate Rises
Moishe Alexander says CMHC’s availability rate measures the percentage of units for which the existing tenant has given or received notice to move and a new tenant has not been found for the unit. The rate also includes those units that are currently empty or vacant and as such the availability rate is always higher than the vacancy rate. Availability rates give a slightly broader indication of the trends in the available rental supply.
High availability rates indicate that the movement from rental to homeownership continues, although it is not as strong as in the past. It also indicates that with the numerous vacant units available, renters are easily able to move among units if a better unit becomes available. For the Windsor CMA, the availability rate increased from 14.4 per cent in October 2007 to 16.8 per cent in October 2008. The difference between the vacancy rate and the availability rate stands at 2.4 per cent in the Windsor CMA. The higher availability rate suggests that turnover among tenants has been relatively high.
Rental Affordability
Moishe Alexander says The rental affordability indicator is a gauge of how affordable a rental market is for those households which rent within that market. A generally accepted rule of thumb for affordability is that a household should spend less than 30 per cent of its gross income on housing. The new rental affordability indicator examines a three-year moving average of median income of renter households and compares it to the median rent for a two-bedroom apartment in the centre in which they live. More specifically, the level of income required for a household to rent a median priced two-bedroom apartment, using 30 per cent of its income, is calculated. The threeyear moving average of median income of households in a centre is then divided by this required income. The resulting number is then multiplied by 100 to form the indicator. An indicator value of 100 indicates that 30 per cent of the median income of renter households is necessary to rent a two-bedroom apartment going at the median rental rate. A value above 100 indicates that less than 30 per cent of the median income is required to rent a twobedroom apartment, conversely, a value below 100 indicates that more than 30 per cent of the median income is required to rent the same unit. In general, as the indicator increases, the market becomes more affordable; as the indicator declines, the market becomes less affordable.
According to CMHC’s new rental affordability indicator which moved from 86 in 2007 to 93 in 2008, affordability in Windsor’s rental market improved for the fourth year in a row.
Rental Market Outlook
Moishe Alexander says The average rental apartment vacancy rate will remain high in 2009, peaking at 17 per cent. A moderating economy will dampen both rental and ownership demand. Continuing out-migration, especially of the prime renter 18-24 year old age group, from the Windsor area in search of job opportunities will contribute to the surplus of vacant apartments. Employment levels will begin to slowly improve towards the end of 2009 as construction of the new $1.5 billion border crossing gets under way. Rent increases will be virtually nonexistent as landlords try to maintain rents on paper and offer other incentives to keep and attract tenants.
You can find the entire report in PDF format through the following link:
http://www.cmhc-schl.gc.ca/odpub/esub/64407/64407_2008_A01.pdf
Posted: February 24, 2009 at 7:58 pm | Tags: Alexander, Area, canadian funding corp, canadian funding corporation, cent, CMA, CMHC, demand, district, end, fact, home, Impact, increase, market, moishe alexander, October, percentage, Quebec, Rate, rent, Rental Market, renter, retirement, Rock Forest, Sherbrooke, Vacancy, West, year
February 24, 2009 — Moishe Alexander’s review on how the current world economy and Canadian economic turndown is affecting the Sherbrooke Rental Market
Moishe Alexander’s Review
Highlights
Moishe Alexander says the rental apartment vacancy rate went up again in the Sherbrooke census metropolitan area (CMA). After climbing by 1.2 percentage points in 2007 to 2.4 per cent, the vacancy rate continued to increase in 2008, reaching 2.8 per cent. The rental market has been easing for five years. The estimated change in the average apartment rent was 2.1 per cent between the October 2007 and October 2008 surveys in the Sherbrooke CMA.
Higher vacancy rate in 2008
Moishe Alexander says According to the results of the latest CMHC Rental Market Survey conducted in 2008, the rental apartment vacancy rate1 went up again in the Sherbrooke census metropolitan area (CMA). After climbing by 1.2 percentage points in 2007 to 2.4 per cent, the vacancy rate continued to increase in 2008, reaching 2.8 per cent. As shown in Figure 2, the rental market has in fact been easing for five years.
In the other CMAs across the province, the vacancy rate increased only in the Trois-Rivières area (from 1.5 per cent in 2007 to 1.7 per cent in 2008). The vacancy rates fell in the Montréal CMA, the Gatineau area and the Saguenay CMA, to 2.4 per cent, 1.9 per cent and 1.6 per cent, respectively, for decreases of 0.5, 1.0 and 1.2 percentage points. It was in the Québec area, however, that the market was the tightest, with fewer than 1 per cent of the apartments vacant there.
Supply remains stable but demand moderates
Moishe Alexander says The vacancy rate increase in the Sherbrooke CMA in 2008 resulted from a moderating demand and stable supply. The number of units in the rental housing stock dropped by 6 per cent in the CMA (from 32,891 units in 2007 to 30,842 units in 2008), but this decrease was mainly caused by the withdrawal of retirement home apartments from our 2008 survey universe. Given this change, supply effectively remained fairly stable between 2007 and 2008 (-1 per cent). At first glance, the stability of the rental housing universe may seem surprising. In fact, between our October 2007 and October 2008 surveys, just over 300 traditional rental apartments were completed, which should normally have increased supply on the market. However, as mentioned earlier, the rental housing stock decreased by 300 units.
This does not necessarily mean that there were fewer rental units on the market this year than last year. It is possible that a number of buildings had to be temporarily withdrawn from the survey universe, as they contained fewer than three rental units. This can occur when one of the apartments in a three-unit building is occupied by the owner. On the demand side, migrants who come to an area, whether from other areas of Quebec or elsewhere, are definitely one of the main factors. In fact, most newcomers to an area choose to rent when they arrive.
Preliminary data2 show that fewer immigrants planned to settle in the Estrie area in 2008. At the end of the first half of 2008, the data showed a decrease of 7 per cent compared to the same period in 2007 (about 40 fewer people). Should the data turn out to be accurate, the decline in immigration in 2008 could therefore be partly responsible for the increase in the vacancy rate this year. In addition, still attracted by the abundance of job opportunities out West, people from Sherbrooke may have continued to move there, lowering net migration in the CMA and weakening potential demand for rental units.
Another factor that may have contributed to the rise in the vacancy rate is the fact that the labour market has been less favourable to young people since the end of 2007, which may have caused some of them to delay leaving the family home, further moderating demand for rental apartments.
Impact of homeownership
Moishe Alexander says As we have already mentioned, the proportion of vacant rental units has been increasing for a few years now in the Sherbrooke CMA. In recent years, sales of existing and new homes have remained strong, suggesting that many renter households made the transition to homeownership, which therefore pushed up the vacancy rate.
In fact, young households now account for a slightly smaller share of rental market clients, as indicated by the 2001 and 2006 census data. It is likely that a greater number of young households are now moving straight to homeownership and bypassing the rental market, also contributing to driving up the vacancy rate. While there are no data to confirm or refute this hypothesis, many younger people may have been attracted to buying homes, such as condominiums, which are more affordable. In fact, sales of new and existing condominiums increased significantly in 2007 and 2008 in the Sherbrooke CMA. It should also be mentioned that financing conditions are still favourable to home buying, such that young households can consider becoming homeowners.
Market easing for larger units
Moishe Alexander says As was the case last year, bachelor units posted the least tight conditions on the rental market, with a vacancy rate of 4.9 per cent in 2008. As well, the market eased for apartments with three or more bedrooms, with the vacancy rate increasing by 1.4 percentage points between the last two October surveys (1.4 per cent in 2007, versus 2.8 per cent in 2008). The decrease in the number of immigrant families, often larger than families who are native to the area3, may have contributed to the increase in the percentage of unoccupied units in this category. The vacancy rate for two-bedroom apartments also rose, but to a lesser extent.
Vacancy rates up in almost all sectors of the CMA
Moishe Alexander says The vacancy rates in the west and central districts of the city of Sherbrooke increased in 2008. Having now surpassed 3 per cent in both districts. Among all the zones in the CMA, the west district posted the largest year-over-year vacancy rate increase (+1.7 percentage points). Students from the Université de Sherbrooke usually fuelled demand for rental units in that sector. While this policy had no impact last year, free public transit for students may have encouraged some to look further away from campus for an apartment that would better meet their needs. While the vacancy rate rose for all unit types combined, rental market conditions in the west district particularly eased for bachelor apartments, which are usually popular with students. In fact, the proportion of vacant units in this category jumped from 1.8 per cent to 7.9 per cent. In the former city of Sherbrooke, the east district recorded the smallest percentage of unoccupied units (1.9 per cent). In fact, it was in this district that the withdrawal of retirement home apartments from our survey universe this year had the greatest impact. In effect, by including retirement homes, the 2007 vacancy rate was much higher there. It should be recalled that our latest retirement home market survey report showed that many rental units were vacant in the east district.
The vacancy rates also increased
Moishe Alexander says year-over-year in the former suburbs of Rock Forest (from 1.2 per cent to 1.4 percent), Fleurimont (from 1.4 per cent to 2.1 per cent) and Ascot–Lennoxville (from 3.8 per cent to 5.1 per cent). However, rental units in these sectors account for less than 25 per cent of the total rental housing stock in the CMA. Contrary to the other sectors of the CMA, the Magog area saw its vacancy rate drop to 2.9 per cent in 2008 (from 3.3 per cent in 2007). With the regional manufacturing sector experiencing difficulties, some renter families likely decided to postpone the purchase of a home. In fact, market conditions got tighter for units with three or more bedrooms, as their vacancy rate fell by 1.9 percentage points (from 4.8 per cent in 2007 to 2.9 per cent in 2008). With sales of existing singlefamily houses having fallen significantly in the area in 2008, larger apartments may have become the best compromise for renter families in the current economic environment. It is also possible that workers seeking better job prospects left the area, further moderating the rental housing demand.
Rents in 2008
Moishe Alexander says The estimated change in the average apartment rent was 2.1 per cent between the October 2007 and October 2008 surveys in the Sherbrooke CMA. Apart from onebedroom units, for which the average rent rose by 4.2 per cent, the other unit types recorded increases of around 2 per cent. The average rent for two-bedroom apartments reached $543 while, for apartments with three or more bedrooms, the average attained $658. The average rents for bachelor apartments and one-bedroom units, for their part, rose to $368 and $437, respectively.
Older buildings bear the brunt of the easing rental market
Moishe Alexander says In the CMA, there were greater proportions of vacant units in rental structures built before 1990 (see Table 1.2.1). Buildings completed from 1960 to 1974 posted the highest vacancy rate (3.6 per cent). Conversely, very few apartments were vacant in structures built from 1990 to 1999, which had a vacancy rate slightly above zero (0.4 per cent).
The trend observed in the last few years for smaller structures (with three to five units) continued, as they still posted the lowest vacancy rate (1.7 per cent). This result contrasted with that of residential buildings with 20 to 99 units, for which the vacancy rate was slightly below 4 per cent.
Rental affordability falls slightly
Moishe Alexander says CMHC’s rental affordability indicator4 is a gauge of how affordable a rental market is for those households which rent within that market. In 2008, the affordability indicator4 was 128, compared to 133 in 2007. While rental affordability has decreased, Sherbrooke area households continued to spend less than 30 per cent of their gross income on rent, as they have for the last ten years. In 1998, the indicator had dropped below 100, reaching 93.
In addition, a review of the data for two-bedroom apartments, which do account for over half of the rental housing stock in the CMA, reveals that affordable units remained the (from 3.3 per cent in 2007). With the regional manufacturing sector experiencing difficulties, some renter families likely decided to postpone the purchase of a home. In fact, market conditions got tighter for units with three or more bedrooms, as their vacancy rate fell by 1.9 percentage points (from 4.8 per cent in 2007 to 2.9 per cent in 2008). With sales of existing singlefamily houses having fallen significantly in the area in 2008, larger apartments may have become the best compromise for renter families in the current economic environment. It is also possible that workers seeking better job prospects left the area, further moderating the rental housing demand.
Rents in 2008
Moishe Alexander says The estimated change in the average apartment rent was 2.1 per cent between the October 2007 and October 2008 surveys in the Sherbrooke CMA. Apart from one bedroom units, for which the average rent rose by 4.2 per cent, the other unit types recorded increases of around 2 per cent. The average rent for two-bedroom apartments reached $543 while, for apartments with three or more bedrooms, the average attained $658. The average rents for bachelor apartments and one-bedroom units, for their part, rose to $368 and $437, respectively.
You can find the entire report in PDF format through the following link:
http://www.cmhc-schl.gc.ca/odpub/esub/64447/64447_2008_A01.pdf